Skip to content

CFE-3041: testall should fail a regular acceptance test if it prints errors#6224

Open
sarakthon wants to merge 1 commit into
cfengine:masterfrom
sarakthon:testall-fail-on-error
Open

CFE-3041: testall should fail a regular acceptance test if it prints errors#6224
sarakthon wants to merge 1 commit into
cfengine:masterfrom
sarakthon:testall-fail-on-error

Conversation

@sarakthon

@sarakthon sarakthon commented Jul 9, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Ticket: CFE-3041

Running testall before changes (just a snippet from terminal):

./00_basics/01_compiler/string_contexts.cf Pass
./00_basics/01_compiler/string_contexts.x.cf Pass
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_comma_args FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
2.cf FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_comma_paramlist FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
2.cf FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_commas FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
2.cf FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_commas.cf Pass
./00_basics/01_compiler/with_iteration.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/001.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/002.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/003.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/004.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/005.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/006.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/008.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/010.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/dry_run_perms_doesnt_lie.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/show-evaluated-vars.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/staging/007.cf Skipped (Staging tests are disabled)
./00_basics/02_switches/staging/009.cf Skipped (Staging tests are disabled)
./00_basics/02_switches/staging/negate_hard_class.cf Skipped (Staging tests are disabled)
./00_basics/03_bodies/001.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/002.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/003.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/101.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/102.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/103.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/104.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/109.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/112.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/113.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/114.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/115.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/116.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/117.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/118.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/119.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/120.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/121.cf Pass
...
...
Passed tests:    1632
Failed tests:    130
Skipped tests:   235
Soft failures:   75
Flakey failures: 0
Total tests:     2072

After changes:

./00_basics/01_compiler/string_contexts.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/string_contexts.x.cf Pass
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_comma_args FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
2.cf FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_comma_paramlist FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
2.cf FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_commas FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
2.cf FAIL (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/01_compiler/trailing_commas.cf Pass
./00_basics/01_compiler/with_iteration.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/001.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/002.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/003.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/004.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/005.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/006.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/008.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/010.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/dry_run_perms_doesnt_lie.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/show-evaluated-vars.cf Pass
./00_basics/02_switches/staging/007.cf Skipped (Staging tests are disabled)
./00_basics/02_switches/staging/009.cf Skipped (Staging tests are disabled)
./00_basics/02_switches/staging/negate_hard_class.cf Skipped (Staging tests are disabled)
./00_basics/03_bodies/001.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/002.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/03_bodies/003.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/101.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/102.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/103.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/104.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/109.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/112.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/03_bodies/113.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/03_bodies/114.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/115.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/116.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/117.cf Pass
./00_basics/03_bodies/118.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/03_bodies/119.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/03_bodies/120.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
./00_basics/03_bodies/121.cf FAIL (Test passed, but printed error message(s)) (UNEXPECTED FAILURE)
...
...
Passed tests:    1319
Failed tests:    442
Skipped tests:   235
Soft failures:   75
Flakey failures: 0
Total tests:     2071

Next I'm going to look into the tests that now fail with these new changes, and investigate the error messages.

@CLAassistant

Copy link
Copy Markdown

CLA assistant check
Thank you for your submission! We really appreciate it. Like many open source projects, we ask that you sign our Contributor License Agreement before we can accept your contribution.
You have signed the CLA already but the status is still pending? Let us recheck it.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants