[ADD] Blog post providing book review of Animal Farm. - #25
Conversation
ultimatecoder
commented
Dec 17, 2017
- Description: A blog post describing my book review of the Animal Farm. Please write your comments here in the PR. I am expecting help with grammar and sentence composition. Thanks!
5cda202 to
571bb7a
Compare
5a445fc to
1136b6a
Compare
jesusinadidas
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I'm on my phone and typing isn't much fun, so I just looked over the first section. Here are some ideas:
Animal Farm is one of the better books I've encountered [Encountered where? In my life? During my time as a student? Maybe add clarification here]. Written in 1945 by English author Eric Arthur Blair under his pen name George Orwell [I'd consider dropping this reference to his legal name and simply referring to him as "George Orwell", unless you're going to add a lot more information about his background], it is one of his best known and most influential works. [Any references to Orwell's reputation, be it for literary criticism, social commentary, satire, or his influences on modern popular culture and political culture would fit nicely here]
[Probably better to make this a new paragraph and elaborate a bit more on the significance of the following observations:]The sentences are well composed, which aided in my comprehension. The book consists of fewer than 100 pages and I was able to complete it in two sittings [consider omitting the comment on mileage variance, as this is common sense].
f7dc7b1 to
5133149
Compare
scripts/optimize-images made one attempt per photo — 1600px at quality 80 — and accepted whatever came out. For a busy photo that is not enough. The mural in the Animal Farm post settles at 403 KB, 96 KB over budget, and re-encoding it does not help: passes two and three land on 403 KB again. The script still printed its summary and exited 0, so the only signal was scripts/test failing at --check, whose advice is to run this script. That advice was a loop with no exit. Photos now walk down 1600/1400/1200/1000px at quality 80 and keep the widest size that fits. Each attempt re-encodes the untouched original, so a narrow attempt never stacks its loss on a wider one. Narrowing is the right lever here: 1200px/q80 holds edges that 1600px/q65 smears for about the same bytes. Anything still over budget once the ladder bottoms out is now named on stderr and exits non-zero, which covers GIFs too. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The photo went in at 4486x2982 straight off the camera, which no reader needs and every feed reader renders at full size. This is scripts/optimize-images output, not a hand encode: the ladder added in the previous commit steps past 1600px and 1400px, both still over budget, and settles at 1200px/q80. Re-running leaves the file byte-identical. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
jesusinadidas reviewed this in January 2019 and said plainly that they had
only read the first section. All four of their notes are taken:
- "one of the good books I came across during 2017" said nothing about
where. It now names the year as the field it is the best of.
- Eric A. Blair is dropped. The post never uses the legal name again, so
introducing it only slowed the first paragraph down.
- Orwell's reputation gets the sentence they asked for, and the Times
ranking now carries its year (2008).
- The prose observation becomes its own paragraph and says why the
plainness matters. The "your mileage may vary" aside is gone.
The other three sections were never reviewed and needed more work. Pings ->
Pigs, Coincidently -> Coincidentally, Old major -> Old Major. The plot
summary was one 34-line paragraph that switched between past and present
every few sentences; it is now four paragraphs in a consistent literary
present. Verb complementation ("succeed to out the owner"), articles ("take
the revenge", "as consequence"), and a handful of collocations ("inscribed a
deep impression on my soul", "improve in myself") are fixed throughout.
Two details about the book were wrong and are corrected: Snowball is driven
off the farm by Napoleon's dogs rather than assassinated, and Old Major dies
three nights after the meeting, not the next morning.
The image markdown was missing site.baseurl, so the src stayed relative in
production builds and feed readers had nothing to resolve it against. The
alt text now describes the mural instead of saying "title image".
Republished under today's date rather than the December 2017 one it was
written on, and the proofreader credit points at the reviewer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
5133149 to
0d34926
Compare
|
Thanks for the review @jesusinadidas, and apologies that it took this long to come back to it. Every one of your notes is addressed below, and I have credited you as the proofreader on the post. You mentioned you had only looked over the first section. That turned out to matter — the later sections needed more work than the first one, so I went through the whole post. Your notes on the Introduction
The three sections you did not get to
Two details about the book were also wrong and are corrected: Snowball is driven off the farm by Napoleon's dogs rather than assassinated, and Old Major dies three nights after the meeting rather than the next morning. Rebase and CIThe branch is rebased onto current Fixing that exposed a real bug in Photos now walk down 1600/1400/1200/1000px and keep the widest size that fits, re-encoding from the untouched original each time so a narrow attempt never stacks its loss on a wider one. Anything still over budget once the ladder bottoms out is named on stderr and exits non-zero. The title photo is now 229 KB at 1200px, and it is the tool's output rather than a hand encode — re-running leaves it byte-identical. Also fixed the image markdown, which was missing Verified locally before pushing: The post is republished under today's date rather than the December 2017 one it was written on. |