Skip to content

add binary-search-1 solutions#2499

Open
nikhylw wants to merge 1 commit into
super30admin:masterfrom
nikhylw:master
Open

add binary-search-1 solutions#2499
nikhylw wants to merge 1 commit into
super30admin:masterfrom
nikhylw:master

Conversation

@nikhylw
Copy link
Copy Markdown

@nikhylw nikhylw commented May 29, 2026

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Search inside a Rotated Sorted Array (solution1.py)

The binary search implementation for the 2D matrix problem is well-structured and follows best practices. However, you submitted code for the wrong problem. The "Search in Rotated Sorted Array" problem requires handling a single rotated array where you need to determine which half is sorted at each step and adjust your search accordingly. Your current solution treats the input as a 2D matrix and flattens it for binary search, which is a different algorithm entirely. Please implement the solution for the rotated sorted array problem using the standard approach: at each step, determine whether the left or right half is sorted, then check which half the target could be in based on the sorted half's bounds.

VERDICT: NEEDS_IMPROVEMENT


Search Inside a Sorted Array whose Length is unknown (solution2.py)

The student appears to have implemented a solution for a different problem (search in rotated sorted array). To improve:

  1. Understand the problem requirements: The key challenge here is dealing with an array of unknown size. You must use the ArrayReader.get(i) interface to access elements, and handle the case where i is out of bounds (returns 2^31 - 1).

  2. Two-phase approach: First, find the search bounds by exponentially expanding (doubling high until you find a value >= target or hit the boundary). Then perform binary search within those bounds.

  3. Interface usage: Replace direct array access (nums[mid]) with reader.get(mid) calls.

  4. Remove irrelevant logic: The rotated array check (nums[low] <= nums[mid]) is not needed for a standard sorted array.

STRENGTHS:

  • The binary search implementation within the found range is correct
  • Good variable naming and code structure
  • Proper handling of edge cases in binary search

NEEDS_IMPROVEMENT:

  • The solution addresses a different problem entirely
  • Missing the core concept of searching in an unknown-size array
  • Not using the provided ArrayReader interface

VERDICT: NEEDS_IMPROVEMENT


Search a 2D Matrix (solution3.py)

Strengths:

  • Clean, well-structured code with meaningful variable names
  • Correct implementation of exponential search pattern
  • Proper handling of edge cases (checking if low equals target at the end)
  • Efficient O(1) space complexity

Areas for Improvement:

  • The solution addresses a different problem (ArrayReader with infinite sorted array) rather than the 2D matrix search problem described
  • The function signature doesn't match the problem requirements (searchMatrix(int[][] matrix, int target))
  • For the actual 2D matrix problem, a simple binary search treating the 2D array as 1D would be more appropriate

Note: If this is actually a different LeetCode problem (like "Search in a Sorted Array of Unknown Length" - LeetCode 702), then the solution is correct. However, based on the provided problem statement about a 2D matrix, this solution doesn't match the requirements.

VERDICT: NEEDS_IMPROVEMENT

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants