Skip to content

e2e-run-1.3_EN.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
148 lines (116 loc) · 7.4 KB

e2e-run-1.3_EN.md

File metadata and controls

148 lines (116 loc) · 7.4 KB

Textum Workflow Simulation Test Report (E2E)

1. Test Overview

  • Test Date: 2026-01-17
  • Model Version: Claude Opus 4.5 (claude-opus-4-5-20251101) / GPT-5.2-xhigh
  • Test Objective: Validate the end-to-end feasibility and gate effectiveness of Textum Skill-based workflow in "zero-programming user + medium complexity requirements (28 FP, 12 API)" scenario

Test Scope (by Workflow.md stages):

Batch Stage Skill Stage Flow
1 PRD Stage PRD Plan → PRD Check → PRD Render → PRD Slice
2 Scaffold Stage Scaffold Plan → Scaffold Check → Scaffold Render
3 Split Stage Split Plan → Split Plan Check → Split Generate → Split Check1 → Split Check2 → Split Checkout
4 Story Execution Story Check → Story Pack → Story Exec

2. Output Scale

Metric Count
Modules (M-xx) 7
Feature Points (FP-xxx) 28
Business Rules (BR-xxx) 4
Data Tables (TBL-xxx) 21
API Endpoints (API-xxx) 12
Stories 24
PRD Plan Convergence Rounds 6
Scaffold Plan Convergence Rounds 3
Split Plan Convergence Rounds 2

3. Stage Evaluation Results

3.1 PRD Stage (PRD Plan → PRD Check → PRD Render → PRD Slice)

Expected Simulation Result Achievement %
PRD Plan ≤4 questions per round, only blockers 6 rounds convergence, ≤4 questions per round 100%
PRD Plan READY with minimum viable pack modules=7, FP=28, BR=4, api.has_api=true, endpoints=12 100%
PRD Check structure/placeholder/ID consistency PASS 100%
PRD Render generates complete PRD by template Generated PRD.md 100%
PRD Slice generates slice directory Generated prd-slices/ 100%

3.2 Scaffold Stage (Scaffold Plan → Scaffold Check → Scaffold Render)

Expected Simulation Result Achievement %
Scaffold Plan converges and writes scaffold-pack.json 3 rounds convergence 100%
Scaffold Check structure complete PASS 100%
Scaffold Render generates GLOBAL-CONTEXT.md Generated successfully 100%

3.3 Split Stage (Split Plan → Split Plan Check → Split Generate → Split Check1 → Split Check2 → Split Checkout)

Expected Simulation Result Achievement %
Split Plan Story sequential numbering, unique slug Story 1..24; unique slugs 100%
Split Plan Check API threshold pre-check PASS 100%
Split Generate creates 24 story-N-slug.json files Filenames 1:1 with split-plan 100%
Split Check1 threshold gate PASS 100%
Split Check2 reference consistency PASS 100%
Split Checkout generates dependency graph Generated story-mermaid.md 100%

3.4 Story Execution (Story Check → Story Pack → Story Exec)

Story 1 (auth-foundation) was selected for execution validation.

Expected Simulation Result Achievement %
Story Check validates YAML/reference consistency PASS 100%
Story Pack generates exec-pack Generated story-exec/story-001-auth-foundation/ 100%
Story Exec reads only exec-pack Prohibited reading PRD/GC/story-*.json 100%
Story Exec key file coverage server.py/storage.py/auth.py 100%
Story Exec validation command (gate:compile) PASS 100%
Story Exec FP/API coverage FP-001/002/003/004; API-001/002/003 100%

4. Failure Summary

Stage/Step Occurrences Final Status
No failures 0 All PASS

5. Overall Workflow Evaluation

Dimension Compliance % Description
Final output meets user expectations 100% Story 1 acceptance criteria all passed; key files/capabilities fully covered
Gate effectiveness 100% 6 check commands all intercepted/released as expected; threshold/consistency/reference validation without false negatives
Low noise 100% All stages adhered to minimum read scope; Story Exec only read exec-pack
Reusability 100% Command/template structure stable; ID format and anchor mechanism consistent

6. Conclusion

The Textum Skill-based workflow completed the full end-to-end simulation from user requirements to Story execution under Claude Opus 4.5 / GPT-5.2-xhigh model. All 19 steps in the workflow executed as expected, with 6 validation commands (PRD Check, Scaffold Check, Split Plan Check, Split Check1, Split Check2, Story Check) operating effectively as gates.

This test covered a medium-complexity scenario with 7 modules, 28 feature points, 12 APIs, 21 data tables, and 24 Stories. PRD Plan completed requirement convergence within 6 rounds of dialogue, and all validation steps passed on first attempt.

Story 1 (basic login and authentication module) execution output covered 4 feature points (FP-001/002/003/004), 3 APIs (API-001/002/003), and the validation command gate:compile passed.

7. Appendix

A. Executed Steps/Commands

Step (Skill Stage) Corresponding CLI Command Executions Final Result
PRD Plan N/A (interactive) 6 rounds READY
PRD Init uv run textum prd init --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
PRD Check uv run textum prd check --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
PRD Render uv run textum prd render --workspace <WS> --lang auto 1 PASS
PRD Slice uv run textum prd slice --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Scaffold Plan N/A (interactive) 3 rounds READY
Scaffold Init uv run textum scaffold init --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Scaffold Check uv run textum scaffold check --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Scaffold Render uv run textum scaffold render --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Split Plan N/A (interactive) 2 rounds READY
Split Plan Init uv run textum split plan init --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Split Plan Check uv run textum split plan check --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Split Generate uv run textum split generate --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Split Check1 uv run textum split check1 --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Split Check2 uv run textum split check2 --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Split Checkout uv run textum split checkout --workspace <WS> 1 PASS
Story Check uv run textum story check --workspace <WS> --n 1 1 PASS
Story Pack uv run textum story pack --workspace <WS> --n 1 1 PASS
Story Exec (gate:compile) python -m compileall app 1 PASS

Note: CLI commands require execution under uv run --project .codex/skills/textum/scripts environment, <WS> is the workspace path.

B. Generated Documents/Artifacts

File Status
docs/prd-pack.json Generated
docs/PRD.md Generated
docs/prd-slices/ Generated
docs/scaffold-pack.json Generated
docs/GLOBAL-CONTEXT.md Generated
docs/split-plan-pack.json Generated
docs/stories/story-001 ~ story-024 Generated (24 files)
docs/split-check-index-pack.json Generated
docs/story-mermaid.md Generated
docs/story-exec/story-001-auth-foundation/ Generated

C. Generated Code (Story 1)

File Responsibility
app/server.py HTTP server (login/auth API)
app/storage.py SQLite database layer
app/auth.py Authentication and session management