Merge pull request #108 from include-cpp/coc-update

HughMacdonald · web-flow · commit 8d821c914728 · 2022-09-04T18:02:46.000+01:00
Transparency Report and automatic index
diff --git a/_config.yml b/_config.yml
@@ -277,6 +277,7 @@ tag_archive:
 #     category: /categories/:name/
 #     tag: /tags/:name/
 
+categories: [communication, report, cppcon]
 
 # HTML Compression
 # - https://jch.penibelst.de/
diff --git a/_data/navigation.yml b/_data/navigation.yml
@@ -21,13 +21,18 @@ sidebar:
         url: /what-can-i-do/
       - title: "Community sponsors"
         url: /community-sponsors/
+  - title: "Code of Conduct"
+    url: /discord/
+    children:
+      - title: "Our Code of conduct"
+        url: /code-of-conduct/
+      - title: "Transparency reports"
+        url: /reports/
   - title: Discord Server
     url: /discord/
     children:
       - title: "Join Discord"
         url: /discord/
-      - title: "Code of conduct"
-        url: /code-of-conduct/
       - title: "Moderation"
         url: /moderation/
   - title: Conferences and Events
@@ -41,6 +46,8 @@ sidebar:
         url: /conferences/organising-conferences/
       - title: "Toolbox"
         url: https://github.com/include-cpp/toolboxes/blob/main/README.md
+  - title: "Communications"
+    url: /posts/
   - title: "Shop"
     url: /shop/
     children:
diff --git a/index.md b/index.md
@@ -6,13 +6,13 @@ toc: true
 
 ## CppCon Safety
 
-[#include ＜C++＞ update on CppCon](/posts/cppcon-update/)
-
-[#include ＜C++＞ stands with Patricia](/posts/patricia-statement-of-support/)
-
-[Our communication regarding CppCon 2021.](/posts/communication-cppcon/)
-
-[About the unapproved release of some working documents.](/posts/communication-working-document/)
+<ul>
+  {% for page in site.pages reversed %}
+    {% if page.categories contains 'cppcon' %}
+        <li><a href="{{ page.url }}">{{ page.title }}</a></li>
+    {% endif %}   <!-- resource-p -->
+  {% endfor %}  <!-- page -->
+</ul>
 
 {% include_relative conferences/current_funding_campaign.md %}
 
diff --git a/moderation.md b/moderation.md
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ title: "#include ＜C++＞ Discord Moderation Guidelines"
 Introduction
 ------------
 
-It is important that all users’ questions, answers and comments are in line with the [`#include` Discord Code of Conduct]({{site.baseurl}}/code-of-conduct), as well as with the category and topic, or channel, they belong to. When deciding to approach a user, moderators and administrators must always assume intentions are good, which is usually the case. Over-moderation is harmful to the atmosphere of the community and should be avoided.
+It is important that all users’ questions, answers and comments are in line with the [`#include ＜C++＞` Code of Conduct]({{site.baseurl}}/code-of-conduct), as well as with the category and topic, or channel, they belong to. When deciding to approach a user, moderators and administrators must always assume intentions are good, which is usually the case. Over-moderation is harmful to the atmosphere of the community and should be avoided.
 
 Expectations for moderator enforcement
 --------------------------------------
diff --git a/posts/20220308-communication-working-document.md b/posts/20220308-communication-working-document.md
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 ---
 layout: archive
 title: "Communication about our working document"
+categories: [communication, cppcon]
 ---
 
 8 March 2022
diff --git a/posts/20220314-communication-cppcon.md b/posts/20220314-communication-cppcon.md
@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 layout: home
 title: "#include ＜C++＞ Position on CppCon Safety"
 toc: true
+categories: [communication, cppcon]
 ---
 
 14 March 2022
diff --git a/posts/20220318-patricia-statement-of-support.md b/posts/20220318-patricia-statement-of-support.md
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 ---
 layout: archive
 title: "#include ＜C++＞ stands with Patricia"
+categories: [communication, cppcon]
 ---
 
 18 March 2022
diff --git a/posts/20220623-cppcon-update.md b/posts/20220623-cppcon-update.md
@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 layout: home
 title: "#include ＜C++＞ Update on CppCon"
 toc: true
+categories: [communication, cppcon]
 ---
 
 23 June 2022
diff --git a/posts/index.md b/posts/index.md
@@ -1,12 +1,12 @@
 ---
 layout: home
-title: "Our Posts"
+title: "Our Communications"
 ---
 
-[#include ＜C++＞ update on CppCon](/posts/cppcon-update/)
-
-[#include ＜C++＞ stands with Patricia](/posts/patricia-statement-of-support/)
-
-[Our communication regarding CppCon 2021.](/posts/communication-cppcon/)
-
-[About the unapproved release of some working documents.](/posts/communication-working-document/)
+<ul>
+  {% for page in site.pages reversed %}
+    {% if page.categories contains 'communication' %}
+        <li><a href="{{ page.url }}">{{ page.title }}</a></li>
+    {% endif %}   <!-- resource-p -->
+  {% endfor %}  <!-- page -->
+</ul>
diff --git a/reports/20220720_report.md b/reports/20220720_report.md
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
+---
+layout: home
+title: "July 20th 2022 Transparency Report"
+toc: true
+categories: [report]
+---
+
+`#include ＜C++＞` is an unincorporated international group of volunteers, who conduct business through a discord server.
+
+On July 20th 2022 a `#include ＜C++＞` code of conduct complaint was raised against an admin. The subject of the complaint was a tweet posted on the admin's personal Twitter account that was strongly disparaging toward two prominent C++ community members. The plaintiff arguments were that this tweet was against our mission of building a friendly community and that the tweet could be considered as libel which was a crime.
+
+The recipient of the complaint spoke to the admins except for the target of the complaint. They decided to create a separate discord server and invite moderators from the `#include ＜C++＞` server to discuss the complaint. Eleven moderators and admins joined the discussion, which commenced on July 21st.
+
+The team decided that the tweet was not a violation of the `#include ＜C++＞` code of conduct in the way that the reporter flagged (9 no)
+
+The team decided that the tweet was not a violation of any other part of the code of conduct. (9 no)
+
+The team decided that there should be no immediate adjustment to the code of conduct. There was no agreement whether there should be later adjustment. (1 yes, 4 no, 4 later)
+
+There was strong agreement that the team issue a response to the person the report was against.
+(9 yes)
+
+The team reported back to the reported individual to tell them about the complaint and inform them that it was not considered a breach of the CoC. In the same report, the team also gave feedback on the tweet, pointing out concerns some of the members of the team had, but without requiring any specific action from the reported individual.
+This was supported by 8 members, a two-thirds majority. The message was sent to the subject of the complaint at July 25th 2022, 19:14 UTC
+
+During discussion, the group agreed to pin a new tweet to the #include twitter account:
+
+> “#​include ＜C++＞ is an international group of volunteers with plural and diverse opinions and backgrounds. It cannot be assumed that a personal tweet can represent our position: only tweets from this account do so. They are arrived at by building consensus, which can be very slow.”
+
+It should be noted that none of the agreements reported here were unanimous: although there were no objections to some proposals, there were abstentions on every vote.
+
+Also, there was no recorded process for handling CoC complaints. This will be addressed shortly. Historically, we have used channels with participation restricted to organisers, moderators and admins.
diff --git a/reports/index.md b/reports/index.md
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
+---
+layout: home
+title: "Reports"
+---
+
+<ul>
+  {% for page in site.pages reversed %}
+    {% if page.categories contains 'report' %}
+        <li><a href="{{ page.url }}">{{ page.title }}</a></li>
+    {% endif %}   <!-- resource-p -->
+  {% endfor %}  <!-- page -->
+</ul>
