Skip to content

Minimum ISC criteria count: 4 or 8? #5

@m4nt0de4

Description

@m4nt0de4

The Ambiguity

v0.5.9 states two different minimums for Ideal State Criteria:

Says 8:

OBSERVE phase (line ~95): "Minimum 8 IDEAL STATE Criteria, 8-12 words each"

Says 4:

Quality Gate QG1 (line ~98): ">= 4 criteria exist"
ISC Requirements table (line ~327): "Minimum 4 criteria"
"Even 'fix a typo' has: file changed, typo gone, no new typos introduced, build passes" (4 criteria)

Question

Is the canonical minimum 4 (with 8 as guidance for non-trivial tasks) or 8 (always, even for trivial tasks)?

The fix-a-typo example with exactly 4 criteria suggests 4 is the real floor, but the OBSERVE phase text says 8.

Location

  • "Minimum 8": line ~95 in versions/TheAlgorithm_Latest.md
  • ">=4": lines ~98, ~327, ~378

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions