Two discs in the test collection are reported as no recognised filesystem. They are filed as "SampleCell", and the working assumption was that ER at byte 0 was an unknown sampler format. It is not — and knowing what it actually is changes the scope considerably.
Which layer
Filesystem. These are Macintosh HFS volumes behind an Apple Partition Map. There is no proprietary sampler filesystem involved at all.
Sampler / hardware
Digidesign SampleCell — a Mac NuBook/PCI sampler card, so its libraries shipped as ordinary Mac media rather than as a sampler-native disc.
What's known about the format
ER is the Apple Driver Descriptor Record, not a magic of ours
Block 0 is a standard Apple DDR (sbSig = 0x4552, 'ER'), and the fields check out against the images:
| Field |
Vol. 1 |
Vol. 2 |
sbSig |
0x4552 |
0x4552 |
sbBlkSize |
512 |
512 |
sbBlkCount |
576 983 |
576 998 |
| Image size |
577 800 × 512 |
577 600 × 512 |
Apple Partition Map at block 1
Vol. 1 carries four entries, Vol. 2 one:
Vol. 1 'Apple' Apple_partition_map start 1 63 blocks
'Silverlining' Apple_Driver start 64 32 blocks
'M/O a' Apple_HFS start 96 576400 blocks
'Extra' Apple_Free start 576496 487 blocks
Vol. 2 'Macintosh' Apple_HFS start 32 576966 blocks
Silverlining is the well-known Mac disk driver; Vol. 2's block 4 additionally carries Copyright © 1988-91 Pinnacle Micro, Inc., a Cirrus 295MB (SCSI #0) drive string and 68k driver code. These are magneto-optical removable cartridges, not pressed CD-ROMs — which is also why the partition layouts differ between the two volumes.
HFS volumes, and the payload is AIFF
Reading the Master Directory Block at partition start + 1024:
|
Vol. 1 |
Vol. 2 |
| MDB signature |
0x4244 ('BD', HFS) |
0x4244 |
| Volume name |
Sonic Images V1 |
Sonic Images V2 |
| Files / dirs |
926 / 79 |
404 / 52 |
| Allocation block size |
5 120 |
4 608 |
Marker counts across each volume: Vol. 1 has 708 FORM and 5 352 AIFF; Vol. 2 has 132 FORM, 1 121 AIFF and 74 Sd2f (Sound Designer II).
So the audio is standard AIFF. Once HFS can be walked, this is the same shape as the existing ISO 9660 backend, which already classifies and copies .aiff payloads.
What supporting it would take
- Apple Partition Map parsing — small, and it fits the existing origin probe (ADR-0005) rather than needing anything new: the partition map says where the filesystem starts.
fs/hfs.py — the real work. HFS is well documented (Inside Macintosh: Files) but it is a full B-tree filesystem, considerably more than the ISO 9660 backend.
- Nothing at the sample layer — the payload is AIFF, already handled as a copy.
Worth deciding first
HFS is a general-purpose Mac filesystem, not a sampler filesystem, so this is a genuine scope question rather than an obvious yes. The argument in favour is the one already made for ISO 9660: a meaningful share of these collections are not sampler-format discs, and reading them costs a module and saves the user a second tool. The argument against is that anyone with a Mac, or hfsutils, or 7-Zip can already mount these — unlike an AKAI or E-mu disc, where nothing else will.
I lean toward documenting it and not building it, unless more SampleCell discs turn up. Two specimens, both from the same library, and both readable by existing tools.
A free oracle if anyone does build it
The same library exists in this collection in AKAI form — Optical Media International (OMI) - Sonic Images Universe Of Sounds Vol.1, which is mislabelled by its archive as a Roland S-770 disc but is AKAI, and reads today: 28 volumes, 636 samples.
So an HFS implementation can be checked against a known-good extraction of the same sounds, rather than against "the WAVs sound plausible". That is a much better position than most new formats start from.
Discs referenced (not attached, per ADR-0008):
OMI Universe of Sounds Sonic Images Vol. 1 (SampleCell).iso (295 833 600 bytes) and Vol. 2 (295 731 200 bytes), both from archive-oldschoolscds.
Two discs in the test collection are reported as
no recognised filesystem. They are filed as "SampleCell", and the working assumption was thatERat byte 0 was an unknown sampler format. It is not — and knowing what it actually is changes the scope considerably.Which layer
Filesystem. These are Macintosh HFS volumes behind an Apple Partition Map. There is no proprietary sampler filesystem involved at all.
Sampler / hardware
Digidesign SampleCell — a Mac NuBook/PCI sampler card, so its libraries shipped as ordinary Mac media rather than as a sampler-native disc.
What's known about the format
ERis the Apple Driver Descriptor Record, not a magic of oursBlock 0 is a standard Apple DDR (
sbSig = 0x4552,'ER'), and the fields check out against the images:sbSig0x45520x4552sbBlkSizesbBlkCountApple Partition Map at block 1
Vol. 1 carries four entries, Vol. 2 one:
Silverliningis the well-known Mac disk driver; Vol. 2's block 4 additionally carriesCopyright © 1988-91 Pinnacle Micro, Inc., aCirrus 295MB (SCSI #0)drive string and 68k driver code. These are magneto-optical removable cartridges, not pressed CD-ROMs — which is also why the partition layouts differ between the two volumes.HFS volumes, and the payload is AIFF
Reading the Master Directory Block at partition start + 1024:
0x4244('BD', HFS)0x4244Sonic Images V1Sonic Images V2Marker counts across each volume: Vol. 1 has 708
FORMand 5 352AIFF; Vol. 2 has 132FORM, 1 121AIFFand 74Sd2f(Sound Designer II).So the audio is standard AIFF. Once HFS can be walked, this is the same shape as the existing ISO 9660 backend, which already classifies and copies
.aiffpayloads.What supporting it would take
fs/hfs.py— the real work. HFS is well documented (Inside Macintosh: Files) but it is a full B-tree filesystem, considerably more than the ISO 9660 backend.Worth deciding first
HFS is a general-purpose Mac filesystem, not a sampler filesystem, so this is a genuine scope question rather than an obvious yes. The argument in favour is the one already made for ISO 9660: a meaningful share of these collections are not sampler-format discs, and reading them costs a module and saves the user a second tool. The argument against is that anyone with a Mac, or
hfsutils, or 7-Zip can already mount these — unlike an AKAI or E-mu disc, where nothing else will.I lean toward documenting it and not building it, unless more SampleCell discs turn up. Two specimens, both from the same library, and both readable by existing tools.
A free oracle if anyone does build it
The same library exists in this collection in AKAI form —
Optical Media International (OMI) - Sonic Images Universe Of Sounds Vol.1, which is mislabelled by its archive as a Roland S-770 disc but is AKAI, and reads today: 28 volumes, 636 samples.So an HFS implementation can be checked against a known-good extraction of the same sounds, rather than against "the WAVs sound plausible". That is a much better position than most new formats start from.
Discs referenced (not attached, per ADR-0008):
OMI Universe of Sounds Sonic Images Vol. 1 (SampleCell).iso(295 833 600 bytes) andVol. 2(295 731 200 bytes), both from archive-oldschoolscds.