Skip to content

Restored history with filter_restored_tool_context can be Converse-invalid (assistant-prefill ValidationException) #547

Description

@dtaniwaki

Describe the bug

When AgentCoreMemorySessionManager is configured with filter_restored_tool_context=True, restoring a session can produce a message array that Bedrock Converse rejects.

_filter_restored_tool_context strips toolUse/toolResult blocks from restored history. A user turn that carried only a toolResult becomes empty and is dropped. Dropping it leaves the two surrounding assistant turns adjacent, which breaks Converse's strict role alternation. The history can also end up starting on an assistant turn.

On the next invocation Bedrock rejects the array. On models that reject assistant prefill it surfaces as:

ValidationException (ConverseStream): This model does not support assistant message prefill.
The conversation must end with a user message.

In a Strands agent on AgentCore Runtime this fails the event loop and the invocation returns a 500. The invalid array is built by the tool-use loop plus restore regardless of model — a prefill-tolerant model silently accepts it, so the issue can stay hidden until a model switch surfaces it (observed: the same restored history failed on Claude Opus 4.8 but was accepted by Claude Sonnet 4.6).

To Reproduce

A restored conversation of this shape is enough to trigger it:

user(query) → assistant(text + toolUse) → user(toolResult only) → assistant(answer)
  1. Configure AgentCoreMemoryConfig(..., filter_restored_tool_context=True).
  2. Persist a turn where the assistant calls a tool and the following user turn contains only the toolResult.
  3. Restore the session (e.g. construct a new Agent with the same session manager) and invoke it.
  4. After stripping, the toolResult-only user turn is dropped and the history collapses to two adjacent assistant turns; the next Converse call fails with the ValidationException above.

Expected behavior

After stripping tool blocks, the restored history should stay valid for Bedrock Converse: strict role alternation, starting on a user turn. Adjacent same-role turns left behind by the strip should be merged so the array remains valid once the runtime appends the next user turn before the model call.

Environment

  • bedrock-agentcore (Strands integration: bedrock_agentcore.memory.integrations.strands)
  • Strands agent running on Amazon Bedrock AgentCore Runtime
  • Bedrock model that rejects assistant prefill, ConverseStream

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions