Skip to content

Commit f79da1b

Browse files
ToolboxAidToolboxAid
committed
Refresh PR 176 audit review diff
1 parent 490ab8b commit f79da1b

1 file changed

Lines changed: 285 additions & 14 deletions

File tree

‎dev/reports/codex_review.diff‎

Lines changed: 285 additions & 14 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,20 +1,291 @@
11
diff --git a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_branch-validation.md b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_branch-validation.md
2-
index e20601f15..9a40e1dca 100644
3-
--- a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_branch-validation.md
2+
new file mode 100644
3+
index 000000000..9a40e1dca
4+
--- /dev/null
45
+++ b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_branch-validation.md
5-
@@ -6,4 +6,4 @@
6-
| Worktree clean before branch creation | PASS | `git status --short --branch` showed clean `main`. |
7-
| Local main synced with origin/main | PASS | `git rev-list --left-right --count main...origin/main` returned `0 0`. |
8-
| PR branch created | PASS | Created `PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive`. |
9-
-| Scope is governance/report only | PASS | Changed files are limited to `dev/reports/` plus ignored ZIP output under `tmp/`. |
6+
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
7+
+# PR_26179_OWNER_010 Branch Validation
8+
+
9+
+| Check | Result | Evidence |
10+
+| --- | --- | --- |
11+
+| Start branch was `main` | PASS | `git branch --show-current` returned `main` before branch creation. |
12+
+| Worktree clean before branch creation | PASS | `git status --short --branch` showed clean `main`. |
13+
+| Local main synced with origin/main | PASS | `git rev-list --left-right --count main...origin/main` returned `0 0`. |
14+
+| PR branch created | PASS | Created `PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive`. |
1015
+| Scope is governance/report only | PASS | Changed files are limited to `dev/reports/` plus ignored ZIP output under `dev/workspace/zips/`. |
16+
diff --git a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_manual-validation-notes.md b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_manual-validation-notes.md
17+
new file mode 100644
18+
index 000000000..dd4a69eb9
19+
--- /dev/null
20+
+++ b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_manual-validation-notes.md
21+
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
22+
+# PR_26179_OWNER_010 Manual Validation Notes
23+
+
24+
+## Manual Review
25+
+
26+
+Manually reviewed PR #176 metadata, description, changed files, commits, review comments, review threads, and current-main legal files.
27+
+
28+
+## Findings
29+
+
30+
+- PR #176 is already closed and unmerged.
31+
+- Current `main` already contains the public legal page implementation.
32+
+- Current `main` already contains shared legal navigation with `aria-current="page"`.
33+
+- Current `main` already contains footer legal links.
34+
+- The useful product-facing work was delivered by merged PR #175.
35+
+- PR #176 retained obsolete `docs_build/` provenance/report artifacts.
36+
+- PR #176 has unresolved governance review findings.
37+
+
38+
+## Manual Disposition
39+
+
40+
+Keep PR #176 closed with no replacement.
41+
+
42+
+## Non-Impact
43+
+
44+
+- No runtime files changed.
45+
+- No product pages changed.
46+
+- No API files changed.
47+
+- No database files changed.
48+
+- PR #176 state was not changed.
49+
diff --git a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_report.md b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_report.md
50+
new file mode 100644
51+
index 000000000..e32ba1612
52+
--- /dev/null
53+
+++ b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_report.md
54+
@@ -0,0 +1,162 @@
55+
+# PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive
56+
+
57+
+## Purpose
58+
+
59+
+Archive the read-only forensic audit for PR #176, `PR_26175_OWNER_055: retain legal governance leftovers`, and record the Owner governance disposition.
60+
+
61+
+Final disposition: keep PR #176 closed with no replacement.
62+
+
63+
+## Scope
64+
+
65+
+This is a no-code Owner governance PR.
66+
+
67+
+This PR does not:
68+
+
69+
+- modify runtime code
70+
+- modify product files
71+
+- modify API files
72+
+- modify database files
73+
+- reopen PR #176
74+
+- merge PR #176
75+
+- close any additional PR
76+
+- push changes to any PR branch except this governance report branch
77+
+
78+
+## PR #176 Current State
79+
+
80+
+| Field | Value |
81+
+| --- | --- |
82+
+| PR | #176 |
83+
+| Title | `PR_26175_OWNER_055: retain legal governance leftovers` |
84+
+| State | Closed |
85+
+| Merged | No |
86+
+| Closed at | `2026-06-28T12:44:46Z` |
87+
+| Head branch | `codex/pr-26175-owner-055-legal-governance-leftover-retention` |
88+
+| Head commit | `a539822e26` |
89+
+
90+
+## Original Purpose
91+
+
92+
+PR #176 was opened to retain post-OWNER_054 legal/governance leftover artifacts after the corrected legal package was applied.
93+
+
94+
+The PR intended to preserve:
95+
+
96+
+- legal package implementation/source notes
97+
+- legal foundation package governance notes
98+
+- a generated current-open-PR governance snapshot
99+
+- OWNER_055 validation, checklist, manual notes, changed-files, review-diff, and ZIP outputs
100+
+- confirmation that no `IMPLEMENTATION.md` remained at the repository root
101+
+
102+
+## Changed Files In PR #176
103+
+
104+
+PR #176 changed these files:
105+
+
106+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_055-legal-governance-leftover-retention.md`
107+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_055-legal-governance-leftover-retention_branch-validation.md`
108+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_055-legal-governance-leftover-retention_manual-validation-notes.md`
109+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_055-legal-governance-leftover-retention_requirement-checklist.md`
110+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_055-legal-governance-leftover-retention_validation-lane.md`
111+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_current-open-pr-status.md`
112+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt`
113+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/codex_review.diff`
114+
+- `docs_build/legal/IMPLEMENTATION.md`
115+
+- `docs_build/legal/LEGAL_CHANGELOG.md`
116+
+- `docs_build/pr/PLAN_PR_26175_OWNER_055-legal-governance-leftover-retention.md`
117+
+
118+
+## Unique Requirements Found
119+
+
120+
+The useful requirement content in PR #176 was legal provenance and implementation guidance:
121+
+
122+
+- publish the public legal pages
123+
+- use one shared legal navigation source of truth
124+
+- set `aria-current="page"` on the selected legal page
125+
+- add footer links to legal documents
126+
+- preserve readable and accessible legal pages
127+
+- avoid unrelated runtime, API, database, or product changes
128+
+
129+
+Review comments also identified governance defects:
130+
+
131+
+- `codex_changed_files.txt` lacked required status/stat evidence
132+
+- branch validation passed a nonconforming branch name
133+
+- OWNER_055 sequence number was reused
134+
+- `BUILD_PR` was marked complete without a committed BUILD_PR source doc
135+
+- legal implementation notes pointed at the wrong legal PR identifier
136+
+
137+
+## Implemented Elsewhere
138+
+
139+
+The product-facing legal requirements are already present on current `main`.
140+
+
141+
+Current `main` contains:
142+
+
143+
+- `legal/index.html`
144+
+- `legal/terms-of-service.html`
145+
+- `legal/privacy-policy.html`
146+
+- `legal/cookie-policy.html`
147+
+- `legal/community-guidelines.html`
148+
+- `legal/copyright-policy.html`
149+
+- `legal/dmca-policy.html`
150+
+- `legal/legal-nav.js`
151+
+
152+
+The shared legal navigation source exists in `legal/legal-nav.js` and sets `aria-current="page"` on the current document link.
153+
+
154+
+Footer legal links exist in `assets/theme-v2/partials/footer.html`.
155+
+
156+
+The actual legal package implementation is documented by merged PR #175, `PR_26175_OWNER_054: apply corrected legal package`, and by `dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_054-legal-corrected-package.md`.
157+
+
158+
+## Not Found On Current Main
159+
+
160+
+The exact PR #176 retained leftovers are not present on current `main`:
161+
+
162+
+- `docs_build/legal/IMPLEMENTATION.md`
163+
+- `docs_build/legal/LEGAL_CHANGELOG.md`
164+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_current-open-pr-status.md`
165+
+- OWNER_055-specific report bundle
166+
+- OWNER_055 PLAN document
167+
+
168+
+These are provenance/report artifacts rather than active product implementation requirements.
169+
+
170+
+## Obsolete `docs_build` Conflicts
171+
+
172+
+PR #176 conflicts with current architecture because it uses obsolete repository paths:
173+
+
174+
+- `docs_build/`
175+
+- `docs_build/dev/reports/`
176+
+- `docs_build/pr/`
177+
+- `tmp/`
178+
+
179+
+Current canonical governance and reports live under:
180+
+
181+
+- `dev/build/`
182+
+- `dev/reports/`
183+
+- `dev/workspace/`
184+
+
185+
+Because PR #176 is based on old paths and contains unresolved governance review findings, rebasing it would carry forward stale structure and stale report conventions.
186+
+
187+
+## Lost Requirements Assessment
188+
+
189+
+No active legal product requirement appears lost by keeping PR #176 closed.
190+
+
191+
+The only unique material not on `main` is historical provenance text and stale generated report material. The active legal implementation and user-visible legal page requirements are already present through #175 and current `legal/` files.
192+
+
193+
+If Owner later wants historical provenance preserved, it should be recreated as a small current-path archive note under `dev/reports/` or `dev/build/`, with corrected PR identifiers. No replacement is needed for PR #176 itself.
194+
+
195+
+## Final Disposition
196+
+
197+
+Recommendation: keep PR #176 closed with no replacement.
198+
+
199+
+Reason:
200+
+
201+
+- PR #176 was closed and never merged.
202+
+- Its product-facing legal requirements are already implemented on `main`.
203+
+- Its remaining unique content is stale provenance/report material.
204+
+- It uses obsolete `docs_build/` paths.
205+
+- It has unresolved review comments that would need correction even if the content were preserved.
206+
+- Reopening, rebasing, or completing it would add maintenance overhead without adding active product value.
207+
+
208+
+## Validation Summary
209+
+
210+
+- Branch validation: PASS
211+
+- `git diff --check`: PASS
212+
+- `npm run validate:canonical-structure`: PASS
213+
+- Runtime code changed: No
214+
+- Product files changed: No
215+
+- API/database files changed: No
216+
+- PR #176 state changed: No
11217
diff --git a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_requirement-checklist.md b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_requirement-checklist.md
12-
index f606816f0..ccb71ddbc 100644
13-
--- a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_requirement-checklist.md
218+
new file mode 100644
219+
index 000000000..ccb71ddbc
220+
--- /dev/null
14221
+++ b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_requirement-checklist.md
15-
@@ -15,4 +15,4 @@
16-
| Do not reopen PR #176 | PASS | PR #176 state was not changed. |
17-
| Do not merge or close PRs | PASS | No PR state changes were made. |
18-
| Produce required reports | PASS | Required `dev/reports` files are included. |
19-
-| Produce ZIP under `tmp/` | PASS | ZIP generated under `tmp/` as requested. |
222+
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
223+
+# PR_26179_OWNER_010 Requirement Checklist
224+
+
225+
+| Requirement | Status | Notes |
226+
+| --- | --- | --- |
227+
+| Create no-code Owner governance PR | PASS | This PR archives the PR #176 forensic audit only. |
228+
+| Archive PR #176 forensic audit under current `dev/reports` path | PASS | Audit archived in `dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_report.md`. |
229+
+| Document original purpose | PASS | Included in the report. |
230+
+| Document changed files | PASS | Included in the report. |
231+
+| Document implemented elsewhere | PASS | Current legal pages, legal nav, footer links, and #175 report are cited. |
232+
+| Document not found on main | PASS | PR #176 retained leftovers are listed. |
233+
+| Document obsolete `docs_build` conflicts | PASS | Obsolete path conflicts are called out. |
234+
+| Record final disposition | PASS | Keep PR #176 closed with no replacement. |
235+
+| Do not modify runtime code | PASS | No runtime files changed. |
236+
+| Do not modify product files | PASS | No product files changed. |
237+
+| Do not reopen PR #176 | PASS | PR #176 state was not changed. |
238+
+| Do not merge or close PRs | PASS | No PR state changes were made. |
239+
+| Produce required reports | PASS | Required `dev/reports` files are included. |
20240
+| Produce ZIP under `dev/workspace/zips/` | PASS | ZIP generated under the canonical `dev/workspace/zips/` location. |
241+
diff --git a/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_validation-report.md b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_validation-report.md
242+
new file mode 100644
243+
index 000000000..26ccb7a13
244+
--- /dev/null
245+
+++ b/dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_validation-report.md
246+
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
247+
+# PR_26179_OWNER_010 Validation Report
248+
+
249+
+## Scope
250+
+
251+
+No-code governance/report-only PR.
252+
+
253+
+## Validation Commands
254+
+
255+
+```text
256+
+git diff --check
257+
+npm run validate:canonical-structure
258+
+```
259+
+
260+
+## Results
261+
+
262+
+| Validation | Result | Notes |
263+
+| --- | --- | --- |
264+
+| Branch validation | PASS | Branch created from clean synchronized `main`. |
265+
+| `git diff --check` | PASS | No whitespace errors. |
266+
+| `npm run validate:canonical-structure` | PASS | Canonical repository structure guardrail passed. |
267+
+| Runtime/code change check | PASS | No runtime/code files changed. |
268+
+| Product file check | PASS | No product files changed. |
269+
+| API/database check | PASS | No API/database files changed. |
270+
+| PR #176 state check | PASS | PR #176 was not reopened, merged, or modified. |
271+
+
272+
+## Runtime Validation
273+
+
274+
+Playwright and runtime validation were not run because this PR only adds governance reports under `dev/reports/`.
275+
diff --git a/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt b/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
276+
index 5de14f86d..03d560216 100644
277+
--- a/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
278+
+++ b/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
279+
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
280+
-dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_009-pr-stack-realignment_branch-validation.md
281+
-dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_009-pr-stack-realignment_manual-validation-notes.md
282+
-dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_009-pr-stack-realignment_report.md
283+
-dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_009-pr-stack-realignment_requirement-checklist.md
284+
-dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_009-pr-stack-realignment_validation-report.md
285+
+dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_branch-validation.md
286+
+dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_manual-validation-notes.md
287+
+dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_report.md
288+
+dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_requirement-checklist.md
289+
+dev/reports/PR_26179_OWNER_010-close-pr-176-audit-archive_validation-report.md
290+
dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
291+
dev/reports/codex_review.diff

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)