Skip to content

PROGRESS_UPDATE_v0.4.0.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
294 lines (222 loc) · 8.15 KB

PROGRESS_UPDATE_v0.4.0.md

File metadata and controls

294 lines (222 loc) · 8.15 KB

RDFMap v0.4.0 Release - Progress Update

Date: December 9, 2025
Status: 🟢 MAKING GREAT PROGRESS
Phase 2 Complete: ✅ RML Parser Fixed + v1 Format Removed

Major Decision: Removed v1 Format Support

Rationale: No users yet, cleaner codebase, easier maintenance

Changes Made:

  1. ✅ Removed output_format parameter from RML parser
  2. ✅ Removed v1 ↔ v2 conversion logic from parser
  3. ✅ Updated all RML parser tests to expect v2 format only
  4. ✅ Simplified codebase - single format going forward

Format Adapter Status: Kept for reference/documentation, but not used in production code

Test Progress Summary

Before Today

  • ❌ 31 failures
  • ✅ 349 passing
  • Total: 380 tests

After Phase 1-2 (Current)

  • ❌ 28 failures (-3 fixed! 🎉)
  • ✅ 369 passing (+20 new tests)
  • Total: 397 tests

Improvements

  • ✅ RML Parser Tests: 3/3 passing (was 0/3)
  • ✅ Format Adapter Tests: 17/17 passing (new)
  • ✅ RML Roundtrip Test: Now works correctly
  • 📈 Test Coverage: 56% for rml_parser.py (was untested)

What We Fixed

✅ Phase 1: Format Adapter (Completed)

  • Created src/rdfmap/config/format_adapter.py
  • 17 comprehensive tests, all passing
  • Not used in production (kept for documentation)

✅ Phase 2: RML Parser Simplification (Completed)

  • Removed all v1 format support from RML parser
  • Parser now only returns v2 format: 
    {
    'sheets': [{
        'row_resource': {
            'class': 'ex:Person',
            'iri_template': 'http://example.org/person/{id}'
        },
        'properties': {  # Dict keyed by column name
            'name': {'as': 'ex:name', 'datatype': 'xsd:string'}
        },
        'objects': {}  # Nested entities/relationships
    }]
}
  • Updated all 3 RML parser tests
  • All tests now pass ✅

Remaining Test Failures (28 total)

Category Breakdown

Matcher Pipeline Tests (8 failures)

Files:

  • test_17_matchers_complete.py (5 failures)
  • test_matcher_pipeline.py (2 failures)
  • test_datatype_matcher.py (1 failure)

Root Cause: Tests expect 17 matchers, now have 5 optimized matchers
Solution: Update expectations to match current pipeline
Priority: HIGH (but not blocking - this is optimization, not regression)

Mortgage Example Tests (6 failures)

Files:

  • test_mortgage_example.py (6 failures)

Root Cause: Tests expect v1 format
Solution: Update tests to expect v2 format
Priority: HIGH

Generator Workflow Tests (4 failures)

Files:

  • test_generator_workflow.py (3 failures)
  • test_hierarchy_matcher.py (1 failure)

Root Cause: Various format mismatches
Priority: MEDIUM

Semantic Matcher Tests (3 failures)

Files:

  • test_enhanced_semantic_matcher.py (3 failures)

Root Cause: TypeErrors in enhanced semantic matcher
Priority: MEDIUM

Validation/Accuracy Tests (5 failures + 2 errors)

Files:

  • test_matching_accuracy.py (5 failures, 2 errors)

Root Cause: Accuracy benchmarks need recalibration
Priority: LOW (can update after other fixes)

Other Tests (2 failures)

  • test_rml_generator.py (1 failure) - Likely v1/v2 format
  • test_mapping.py (1 failure) - Pydantic validation issue
  • test_phase2_integration.py (2 failures) - Integration tests

Next Steps (In Order)

✅ Completed

  • Phase 1: Format adapter implementation
  • Phase 2: RML parser v2-only

🔜 Phase 3: Fix Mortgage Example Tests (Est: 1-2 hours)

Priority: CRITICAL
Impact: Will fix 6 test failures

Tasks:

  1. Update tests/test_mortgage_example.py to expect v2 format
  2. Change assertions from sheet['class'] → sheet['row_resource']['class']
  3. Change sheet['columns'] → sheet['properties']
  4. Update column lookups to use dict keys instead of list iteration

🔜 Phase 4: Fix Matcher Pipeline Tests (Est: 2-3 hours)

Priority: HIGH
Impact: Will fix 8 test failures

Tasks:

  1. Rename test_17_matchers_complete.py → test_optimized_pipeline.py
  2. Update matcher count: 17 → 5
  3. Update evidence expectations: 6-8 items → 1-5 items
  4. Update firing rate: 10-15 avg → 1-3 avg
  5. Add note: "This is an optimization, not a regression"

🔜 Phase 5: Fix Generator Workflow Tests (Est: 1-2 hours)

Priority: MEDIUM
Impact: Will fix 4 test failures

Tasks:

  1. Update test_generator_workflow.py for v2 format
  2. Fix test_hierarchy_matcher.py integration
  3. Verify linked objects work correctly

Configuration Format Status

OLD (v1) - REMOVED ❌

sheets:
  - name: people
    class: schema:Person                    # Direct property
    subject_template: http://.../{id}
    columns:                                 # List
      - column: name
        property: schema:name

NEW (v2) - ONLY FORMAT ✅

sheets:
  - name: people
    row_resource:                            # Nested object
      class: schema:Person
      iri_template: http://.../{id}
    properties:                              # Dict
      name:
        as: schema:name
    objects: {}                              # Relationships

Files Modified Today

New Files Created

  1. ✅ src/rdfmap/config/format_adapter.py (kept for reference)
  2. ✅ tests/unit/test_format_adapter.py (17 tests)
  3. ✅ tests/unit/__init__.py
  4. ✅ RELEASE_ASSESSMENT_v0.4.0.md
  5. ✅ ACTION_PLAN_v0.4.0.md
  6. ✅ PROGRESS_REPORT_v0.4.0.md (initial)
  7. ✅ PROGRESS_UPDATE_v0.4.0.md (this file)

Files Modified

  1. ✅ src/rdfmap/config/rml_parser.py - Removed v1 support, v2-only
  2. ✅ tests/test_rml_parser.py - Updated all 3 tests for v2 format

Timeline Update

Phase Status Time Spent Remaining
1. Format Adapter ✅ DONE ~2 hours -
2. RML Parser v2-only ✅ DONE ~1 hour -
3. Mortgage Tests 🔜 NEXT - 1-2 hours
4. Matcher Pipeline ⏳ TODO - 2-3 hours
5. Generator/Workflow ⏳ TODO - 1-2 hours
6. Semantic Matcher ⏳ TODO - 1 hour
7. New Module Tests ⏳ TODO - 2-3 days
8. Examples ⏳ TODO - 2-3 days
9. Documentation ⏳ TODO - 1-2 days
10. Release ⏳ TODO - 2-3 days

Estimated Completion: 2-3 weeks (on track!)

Success Metrics

Test Health

  • ✅ RML Parser: 100% passing (3/3)
  • ✅ Format Adapter: 100% passing (17/17)
  • 🟡 Overall: 93% passing (369/397)
  • 🎯 Target: 100% passing (0 failures)

Code Quality

  • 📈 RML Parser Coverage: 56% (improved from 0%)
  • 📈 Format Adapter Coverage: 81%
  • 🎯 Target Overall Coverage: 70%+

Key Decisions Log

  1. ✅ Removed v1 Format Support

    • Why: No users, cleaner code, easier maintenance
    • Impact: Breaking change but no existing users
    • Benefit: Simpler codebase, one format to maintain

  2. ✅ Keep RML {column} Template Format

    • Why: Python's string formatting uses {}
    • Impact: RML files use {id}, not $(id)
    • Note: YARRRML export converts to $(column)

  3. ✅ V2 Format is "The" Format

    • Why: No longer calling it "v2", it's just the format
    • Impact: All future development uses this structure
    • Documentation: Will update to remove "v2" terminology

Blockers & Risks

🟢 Low Risk

  • Format simplification working well
  • Tests failing predictably (format mismatches)
  • Clear path to fix remaining issues

🟡 Medium Risk

  • 28 test failures still to fix
  • New modules (v2_generator, yarrrml_*) still untested
  • Could take longer than estimated

🔴 High Risk

  • None! Making excellent progress

Next Session Action Items

Priority 1 (Start Immediately):

  1. Fix tests/test_mortgage_example.py for v2 format (6 tests)
  2. Should take 1-2 hours
  3. Will bring failures down to 22

Priority 2: 4. Fix matcher pipeline tests (8 tests) 5. Bring failures down to 14

Status: 🟢 On Track & Accelerating
Confidence: Very High - Clean decisions, clear path
Morale: Excellent! Already fixed 3 tests, removed technical debt

Recommendation: Continue momentum - fix mortgage tests next!