Skip to content

JOSS_READINESS.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
65 lines (51 loc) · 1.99 KB

JOSS_READINESS.md

File metadata and controls

65 lines (51 loc) · 1.99 KB

JOSS Readiness Assessment for pyqt-reactor

Summary

Status: ~70% ready for JOSS submission. Strong paper and documentation, but needs improvements in testing and contribution guidelines.

✅ Strengths

Paper (paper.md)

  • ✅ Clear statement of need with comparison table
  • ✅ Well-articulated software design sections
  • ✅ Real-world application (OpenHCS) demonstrates impact
  • ✅ AI disclosure included
  • ✅ Proper YAML frontmatter with author/affiliation
  • ✅ References section (though needs expansion)

Documentation

  • ✅ Comprehensive Sphinx docs with multiple sections
  • ✅ Quick start guide with working examples
  • ✅ Architecture documentation
  • ✅ API reference (auto-generated from docstrings)
  • ✅ State management and undo/redo guides
  • ✅ Multiple usage examples
  • ✅ ReadTheDocs integration

Code Quality

  • ✅ MIT License
  • ✅ Python 3.11+ support
  • ✅ Type hints throughout
  • ✅ Proper package structure
  • ✅ Dependencies clearly specified

⚠️ Critical Gaps

1. Testing (CRITICAL)

Current: Only 7 test functions across 95 lines Needed: Expand to 20+ tests covering:

  • Form generation from dataclasses
  • Widget creation and value collection
  • FieldChangeDispatcher
  • WindowManager
  • Theming system
  • ObjectState integration

2. Contributing Guidelines (IMPORTANT)

Current: README mentions CONTRIBUTING.md but file doesn't exist Needed: Create CONTRIBUTING.md with development setup, code style, testing requirements

3. Paper References (IMPORTANT)

Current: Only 3 references Needed: Add citations for PyQt6, ObjectState, python-introspect, related frameworks

4. CI/CD Workflows (IMPORTANT)

Current: None Needed: GitHub Actions for testing, coverage, linting

Recommendation

Ready to submit after addressing:

  1. Expand test suite (minimum 20+ tests)
  2. Create CONTRIBUTING.md
  3. Expand paper.bib with 5+ additional references
  4. Add GitHub Actions CI workflow

Estimated effort: 10-17 hours to reach 90%+ readiness